top of page
"The Mystic Seahorse is a gem!! So glad we found you and hope to return! I have to say that your cottage was the best, most stocked place we have ever stayed at. You have the best, most absorbent towels and very comfy beds! We enjoyed the cook outs and fires in the evening very much!"


/ Kaylin and Peggy (Mystic Seahorse)

"We have rented quite a few vacation rentals from VA to FL. The Starlight Inlet feels so much like home. You want for nothing. We found Gwynn's Island by pure accident while searching different beach locations on the Bay. This may be our first time here but won't be our last."


/ Carol and Ricky (Starlight Inlet)

We had a spectacular stay! Thank you so much! Can't wait to come back again one day. Although Haven and Bethel beaches were great, your private beach here was the BEST!


/ Dana and Xavier (Mystic Seahorse)

What a beautiful corner of the world. We so enjoyed this bit of a time capsule in a charming neighborhood. This was our first time on coastal Virginia and we loved the simplicity and quiet. Comfy beds, big bathtub, ample recliners and everything needed for a relaxing time away. We were so happy with how clean everything is. We will never forget this place and hope it's not the last time we ever visit. 

/Dawn, Haythem and Calliope  (Starlight Inlet)

"This was one of the most amazing Airbnb’s I have stayed at. My friend and I were in town for a wedding and were looking for a place close to the wedding venue. This place was fantastic, and you couldn’t beat the price. Check in was extremely easy and at our own convenience. We entered into a beautiful clean adorably decorated cottage with antique decor. They were so gracious to leave goodies for us in the kitchen, including a bottle of wine. The two beds were extremely comfortable and we both slept really well. I would love to return!"


/ Nazly  (Mystic Seahorse)

bottom of page